Skip to main content
Home
  • Connect!
  • Donate
  • My Account
  • Join/Login
  • S
  • Connect!
  • Join/Login
  • Home
  • About
    • What is Social and Personality Psychology?
    • Leadership
      • Elections
    • Get Involved
    • Committees
    • Diversity & Inclusion Initiatives
    • Government Relations
    • Governance Documents
    • Staff
    • Jobs at SPSP
      • Benefits of Working at SPSP
      • Current Openings
  • Members
    • Membership Categories and Rates
    • Member Demographics
    • Member Directory
    • Collaboration Zone
    • APA Division 8
    • Fellows
    • Listservs and Shared Interest Groups
    • Member Deals and Discounts
  • Publications
    • Best Practices
    • Publication Policies
    • Resources
    • PSPB
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation/Submission Guidelines
      • PSPB Online
    • PSPR
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • PSPR Online
    • SPPS
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • SPPS Online
  • Events
    • 2022 Convention
    • Future/Past Conventions
    • Summer Psychology Forum
    • Society of Southeastern Social Psychologists
    • APA Convention (Division 8)
    • Student Opportunities
      • SISPP
      • SPUR
      • EASP
      • EAPP
    • Learning Online
  • Giving
    • Ways to Give
    • Planned Giving
    • Tribute Wall
    • Annual Reports
    • ARP Awards
  • Awards/Grants
    • Annual Awards
      • Senior Career Contribution Awards
      • Mid-Career Awards
      • Early Career Awards
      • Teaching and Mentoring Awards
      • Prizes for a Single Outstanding Contribution
      • Media Awards
      • Service Awards
      • Student Awards
      • Diversity Awards
    • Student Awards
      • Heritage Dissertation Research Award
      • Outstanding Research Award
      • Graduate Student Poster Award
      • Undergraduate Student Poster Award
      • Student Publication Prize
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Diversity Awards
      • Jenessa Shapiro Award for Contributions to Diversity and Inclusion
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Heritage Wall of Fame
    • International Awards
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Legacy Program
    • Travel/Registration Awards
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
      • Teacher & Scholar Travel/Registration Award
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Small Research Grant Program
    • Small Conference Grant Program
    • Community Catalyst Grant Program
  • News
    • Character and Context Blog
    • Member Updates
    • Press Releases
    • Member Newsletter
    • Student Newsletter
  • Resources
    • Connect!
    • Racism, Bias & Diversity
    • Free-Form Fridays
    • Students
      • Graduate Program Directory
      • Applying to Grad School
      • Life in Graduate School
    • Early Career
    • Primarily Undergraduate Institutions
    • Multimedia
      • #SPSPchat
      • SPSP Experts
      • Out of the Lab
      • Convention Videos
    • Funding
    • International Study and Work
    • Statistics & Data Analysis
    • Teaching
      • Recommended Textbooks
      • Syllabi Examples
      • Teaching Aids
      • Video
    • Applied Psychology
  • Careers
    • Find/Post a Job
    • Graduation Outcomes
    • Career Resources
    • Academic Job Market
    • Non-Academic Job Market
    • Undergraduate Research
  • Connect!
  • Join/Login
  • Home
  • About
    • What is Social and Personality Psychology?
    • Leadership
      • Elections
    • Get Involved
    • Committees
    • Diversity & Inclusion Initiatives
    • Government Relations
    • Governance Documents
    • Staff
    • Jobs at SPSP
      • Benefits of Working at SPSP
      • Current Openings
  • Members
    • Membership Categories and Rates
    • Member Demographics
    • Member Directory
    • Collaboration Zone
    • APA Division 8
    • Fellows
    • Listservs and Shared Interest Groups
    • Member Deals and Discounts
  • Publications
    • Best Practices
    • Publication Policies
    • Resources
    • PSPB
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation/Submission Guidelines
      • PSPB Online
    • PSPR
      • Editorial Philosophy
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • PSPR Online
    • SPPS
      • Manuscript Preparation
      • SPPS Online
  • Events
    • 2022 Convention
    • Future/Past Conventions
    • Summer Psychology Forum
    • Society of Southeastern Social Psychologists
    • APA Convention (Division 8)
    • Student Opportunities
      • SISPP
      • SPUR
      • EASP
      • EAPP
    • Learning Online
  • Giving
    • Ways to Give
    • Planned Giving
    • Tribute Wall
    • Annual Reports
    • ARP Awards
  • Awards/Grants
    • Annual Awards
      • Senior Career Contribution Awards
      • Mid-Career Awards
      • Early Career Awards
      • Teaching and Mentoring Awards
      • Prizes for a Single Outstanding Contribution
      • Media Awards
      • Service Awards
      • Student Awards
      • Diversity Awards
    • Student Awards
      • Heritage Dissertation Research Award
      • Outstanding Research Award
      • Graduate Student Poster Award
      • Undergraduate Student Poster Award
      • Student Publication Prize
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Diversity Awards
      • Jenessa Shapiro Award for Contributions to Diversity and Inclusion
      • Jenessa Shapiro Graduate Research Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
    • Heritage Wall of Fame
    • International Awards
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Legacy Program
    • Travel/Registration Awards
      • Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Graduate Travel/Registration Award
      • Diversity Undergraduate Registration Award
      • Teacher & Scholar Travel/Registration Award
      • International Travel/Registration Award
      • International Bridge-Building Award
    • Small Research Grant Program
    • Small Conference Grant Program
    • Community Catalyst Grant Program
  • News
    • Character and Context Blog
    • Member Updates
    • Press Releases
    • Member Newsletter
    • Student Newsletter
  • Resources
    • Connect!
    • Racism, Bias & Diversity
    • Free-Form Fridays
    • Students
      • Graduate Program Directory
      • Applying to Grad School
      • Life in Graduate School
    • Early Career
    • Primarily Undergraduate Institutions
    • Multimedia
      • #SPSPchat
      • SPSP Experts
      • Out of the Lab
      • Convention Videos
    • Funding
    • International Study and Work
    • Statistics & Data Analysis
    • Teaching
      • Recommended Textbooks
      • Syllabi Examples
      • Teaching Aids
      • Video
    • Applied Psychology
  • Careers
    • Find/Post a Job
    • Graduation Outcomes
    • Career Resources
    • Academic Job Market
    • Non-Academic Job Market
    • Undergraduate Research

You are here

Home » News » Character and Context Blog

Character  &  Context

The Science of Who We Are and How We Relate
Editors: Judith Hall, Leah Dickens, Colleen Sinclair

 

Dec 04, 2019

Thinking Enjoyable Thoughts is Hard

by Nick Buttrick
Image of a Young african american woman who looks sad and pensive

Americans are often stereotyped as among the least-reflective people in the world. “Anti-intellectualism is virtually our civic religion,” writes critic A.O. Scott. There’s a longstanding tradition that believes that what’s really important is swift action and pragmatic results, not empty contemplation. In many people’s minds, thinking is just another form of idleness, and instead of spending time with your head in the clouds, you should be out getting things done.

We find that there might be something to this stereotype. In principle, our minds should be among the most potent pleasure-generators we have, far better than any everyday activity. After all, we know our deepest hopes and desires (who better?), and we have the power to conjure up thoughts about whatever we want. When asked to think enjoyable thoughts, we should jump at the chance—and we should succeed. There’s nothing and nobody stopping us from contemplating the most enjoyable things imaginable. Everyday activities, which drag us away from our all-powerful imaginations, shouldn’t be anywhere near as good.

And yet, in study after study, we find that Americans struggle with thinking pleasurable thoughts when instructed to do so, finding the experience mostly “meh.” When given a choice of tasks, research shows that Americans find trying to think for pleasure about as appealing as proofreading or brushing their teeth.  In fact, when presented with a machine that delivers painful electric shocks, a significant proportion of people in our studies choose to shock themselves instead of merely thinking. When forced to think enjoyable thoughts, many Americans flounder.

Is this trouble with generating positive thoughts on command a particularly American problem? On the one hand, Americans do tend to be more action-focused than people from other nations, which might lead them away from the quieter pleasures of thinking. On the other hand, people may struggle to enjoy their thoughts because it’s difficult to force our minds to think about anything for an extended period. Mental control is tricky for most people, regardless of the kind of thought. And, trying to think happy thoughts in particular might backfire, in the same way that trying to feel happy feelings often just makes you feel worse. We therefore set out to learn whether Americans are uniquely bad at retreating into their thoughts, or whether these struggles are common throughout in the world.

With help from social psychologists Rick Klein and Charlie Ebersole, we formed a team of researchers across countries and continents to investigate how much people enjoy thinking fun thoughts and doing fun things. Together, we recruited  over 2,500 research participants from 11 diverse countries: Belgium, Brazil, Costa Rica, Japan, Malaysia, Portugal, Serbia, South Korea, Turkey, the United Arab Emirates, and the United States, Participants at every site were asked to take part in our study only at a time when they were home alone, with time on their hands. Once they’d confirmed that they were ready and that they’d closed everything on their computers except the program running the study, participants were instructed either to spend 12 minutes enjoying their own thoughts or to find something enjoyable to do alone by themselves (such as reading, browsing the internet, or listening to music). Then participants reported back to us about their experiences and filled out a few personality measures.

What do people enjoy more? In every one of our 11 countries, people had a better time doing something enjoyable than thinking enjoyable thoughts. People didn’t hate thinking enjoyable thoughts (their ratings were just below the neutral point of our rating scale), but people clearly enjoyed doing more than thinking. 

Did some people enjoy thinking more than others? Not only were Americans not any worse at enjoying their thoughts than other nationalities, people seemed to struggle to enjoy their thoughts regardless of the type of person they were. On the whole, people across the globe found thinking for pleasure to be difficult—and not very enjoyable. Thinking for pleasure, as it turns out, is hard. Although some people have slightly better ability to control their thoughts or feel slightly more motivated to fulfill this strange request than others, people on the whole had an easier time doing the mundane things they would normally do when alone—and they generally enjoyed them far more.

In 1670, the French philosopher Blaise Pascal argued that “all of humanity’s problems stem from man’s inability to sit quietly in a room, alone.” People have been troubled by—and complained about—the difficulty of enjoying their own thoughts for most of modernity. In this respect, the struggle of Americans to think enjoyably on command marks us as heirs to a rich intellectual tradition.


For Further Reading

Buttrick, N., Choi, H., Wilson, T. D., Oishi, S., Boker, S. M., Gilbert, D. T., Alper, S., Aveyard, M., Cheong, W., Čolić, M. V., Dalgar, I., Doğulu, C., Karabati, S., Kim, E., Knežević, G., Komiya, A., Laclé, C. O., Ambrosio Lage, C., Lazarević, L. B., . . . Wilks, D. C. (2019). Cross-cultural consistency and relativity in the enjoyment of thinking versus doing. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 117(5), e71–e83. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspp0000198

Wilson, T. D., Westgate, E. C., Buttrick, N. R., & Gilbert, D. T. (2019). The mind is its own place: The difficulties and benefits of thinking for pleasure. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 60, 175-221. https://doi.org/10.1016/bs.aesp.2019.05.001

Are you interested in learning more about distributed psychological research? Check out the Psychological Science Accelerator (https://psysciacc.org/), a global network of psychological science laboratories, collaborating to collect psychological data from large-scale international samples.


Nick Buttrick is a doctoral student in social psychology at the University of Virginia.

Tags: 
culture
mental health/well-being
Self

About our Blog

Why is this blog called Character & Context?

Everything that people think, feel, and do is affected by some combination of their personal characteristics and features of the social context they are in at the time. Character & Context explores the latest insights about human behavior from research in personality and social psychology, the scientific field that studies the causes of everyday behaviors.  

□Learn More
□Contribute a Blog to Character & Context

Search the Blog

Get Email Updates from the Blog

Click below to join the Character & Context mailing list.
Subscribe

Popular Articles

Why You Should (Not) Stop Thinking About Work While at Home
Choosing to Be With Other People Matters More to Well-being Than Choosing to Be Alone
The Magical Aura of Insurance
Perceptions of People With Mental Illness as Sexually Exploitable
Finding Your Flow

Share this page
 
Society for Personality and Social Psychology
1120 Connecticut Ave NW, Suite 280
Washington, DC 20036
(202) 869-3240
info@spsp.org
Facebook Icon Twitter Icon LinkedIn Icon
  • Connect!
  • Join/Login
  • Home
  • About
  • Members
  • Publications
  • Events
  • Giving
  • Awards/Grants
  • News
  • Resources
  • Careers
© 2022. Society for Personality and Social Psychology®. All rights reserved.

View our Privacy Policy here.